Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (2024)

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Baseball season or not, one can always use a flavorful, relish-like sauerkraut recipe to add a special zing to a freshly grilled hot dog, barbecued hamburger or just about anything.

When adding sauerkraut to a protein-rich meal, not only doyou get the usual benefits – better digestion, increased nutrition, and support of your immune system – but the probiotics in sauerkraut greatly aid in the digestion of protein. A win-win situation.

If you’re not a fan of onions, don’t despair that this sauerkraut recipe calls for two whole onions. The finished product doesn’t taste strongly of a pungent onion. The fermentation process mellows the onion flavor, which then blends well with the sweet red pepper and the spicy jalapeno to bring up memories of eating a relish-topped hot dog at the ballpark.

Baseball Sauerkraut is just one of many sauerkraut recipes found on my site. Passion Pink? Sweet Garlic?

Note: If this is yourfirst time to make sauerkraut, learn how to choose the best cabbage for sauerkraut and use my teaching recipe:How to Make Sauerkraut In a Jar in 7 Simple Steps [Healthy, Flavorful, Easy], with its step-by-step photography, tips, and additionalfermentation information first, then return to this recipe.

Table of Contents

  • Notes and Tips to Get You Started on Baseball Sauerkraut
    • All About Onions
    • Prepping Jalapeno Peppers, How Much Heat Do You Want?
    • Don’t Want to Irritate Your Hands with the Jalapeno Pepper?
    • Sweet Red Peppers
    • Onion to Cabbage Weight
  • 5 Scrumptious Ways to Use Your Baseball Sauerkraut
    • 1. Straight Out of the Jar
    • 2. Egg or Tuna Salad Sandwich
    • 3. Potato or Macaroni Salad
    • 4. Deviled Eggs
    • 5. Hot Dog? Hamburger?
  • Are You Wanting to Ferment a Whole Crock of Baseball Sauerkraut?
    • The Five Tools I Grab Every Time I Make a Batch of Sauerkraut
  • Infographic: 7 Sauerkraut Recipes (In Short Form) to Tantalize Your Tastebuds
  • Sauerkraut Recipe Infographic

Notes and Tips to Get You Started on Baseball Sauerkraut

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (1)

All About Onions

According to Kirsten and Christopher Shockey, authors of Fermented Vegetables, – my FAVORITE fermentation book, as reviewed here – onions are the only vegetable we know of that lack intrinsic lactic-acid bacteria, the bacteria we need to make fermentation happen. Adding cabbage to the sauerkraut recipe provides enough lactic acid bacteria to solve this problem.

I used white onions in this recipe, but it will work with any type of onion.

Yellow onionshave a nice balance of astringency and sweet in their flavor and are most often used in cooked dishes.

White onionshave a sharper and more pungent flavor than yellow onions. White onions tend to be more tender than yellow onions.

Red onions add a nice color to any dish and are often called for in salads, salsas, and other raw dishes due to their relatively mild flavor.

Prepping Jalapeno Peppers, How Much Heat Do You Want?

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (2)

With hot peppers, the heat is in the seedsandthe inner membrane. Vary the heat by how many seeds you leave in.

If you don’t like super-hot & spicy foods,cut off the stem and slice lengthwise. You might want to wear a glove for this, or be careful and wash your hands well after. With the tip of a knife or a small spoon, scrape the seeds out. To remove even more heat, also scrape out the inner pithy membrane.

If you like the heat,leave in the seeds and inner membrane.

Don’t Want to Irritate Your Hands with the Jalapeno Pepper?

If your hands are sensitive to the capsicum in the jalapeno pepper, don’t add the jalapeno pepper to your bowl until you have mixed all your cabbage and vegetables together and created your brine. Then, add the diced jalapeno, quickly mix and then pack into your jar. You might also want to consider wearing a pair of thin plastic gloves when making this sauerkraut or use a large spoon when mixing and packing.

Sweet Red Peppers

The sweet red pepper adds a nice burst of color to a ferment, a burst of color that fades over time, sadly. In addition, the high water content of peppers causes them to eventually lose their nice fresh crunch.

Onion to Cabbage Weight

For those of you who follow my general guidelines of keeping your “flavoring” ingredients to 25% of the total weight with sliced cabbage making up the remainder, rest assured. This recipe breaks that rule. It is more like an onion relish than sauerkraut. You will probably end up with a good pound of onions. Don’t worry. It will still ferment just fine.

5 Scrumptious Ways to Use Your Baseball Sauerkraut

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (3)

1. Straight Out of the Jar

Don’t complicate matters and just add some to whatever meal you’re having. Simple!

2. Egg or Tuna Salad Sandwich

Finely chop a few spoonfuls of Baseball Sauerkraut and add to your favorite egg or tuna salad recipe. A nice shift from the typical, overly-sweet relish.

3. Potato or Macaroni Salad

Adding a few forkfuls of Baseball Sauerkraut to a potato or macaroni salad will add a punch of tangy flavor.

4. Deviled Eggs

Chop finely and add Baseball Sauerkraut to your next batch of deviled eggs. Sure to be a crowd pleaser.

5. Hot Dog? Hamburger?

The classic combination. Use as a topping for that grilled hot dog. After all, that’s what inspired this recipe. 😉

Also, see my ever-growing list of ways to enjoy your sauerkraut. Check out #13: To-Die-For Pizza Topping!

Are You Wanting to Ferment a Whole Crock of Baseball Sauerkraut?

Quantities for this sauerkraut recipe can easily be adjusted. It’s best to make – and pack your fermenting crock – with successive 5-pound batches (triple the ingredients of a 1-quart batch) until your crock is about 80% full. Follow How to Make Sauerkraut In a Crock in 7 Simple Steps [Healthy, Flavorful, Easy] for all the tips and tricks to ensure a home-run success.

The Five Tools I Grab Every Time I Make a Batch of Sauerkraut

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (4)

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (5)

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (6)

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (7)

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (8)

Fermentation Vessel

Fermentation Weight and Airlock Lid

White Plastic Storage Caps

A Scale: MyWeigh KD-8000 Digital Scale

Himalayan Pink Salt

Quart (Liter) Jar: Wide-Mouth

The Trellis + Co. Pickle Helix Kit is strong enough to hold your ferment below the brine throughout fermentation. Its design leaves plenty of room for brine.

Use for storing your ferments or as your lid during fermentation.

You won't regret owning the "Tesla" of scales. Makes weighing your ingredients and salt a breeze.

My favorite fermentation salt. Broad range of minerals. Adds subtle flavor.

$16.49

$38.77

Price not available

$46.84

$8.95

-

1,654 Reviews

368 Reviews

3,087 Reviews

3,683 Reviews

-

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (9)

Fermentation Vessel

Quart (Liter) Jar: Wide-Mouth

$16.49

1,654 Reviews

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (10)

Fermentation Weight and Airlock Lid

The Trellis + Co. Pickle Helix Kit is strong enough to hold your ferment below the brine throughout fermentation. Its design leaves plenty of room for brine.

$38.77

368 Reviews

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (11)

White Plastic Storage Caps

Use for storing your ferments or as your lid during fermentation.

Price not available

3,087 Reviews

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (12)

A Scale: MyWeigh KD-8000 Digital Scale

You won't regret owning the "Tesla" of scales. Makes weighing your ingredients and salt a breeze.

$46.84

3,683 Reviews

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (13)

Himalayan Pink Salt

My favorite fermentation salt. Broad range of minerals. Adds subtle flavor.

$8.95

-

-

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (14)

Baseball Sauerkraut

FERMENTATION LENGTH: 1-4 weeks

Why do I love this recipe? It’s a flavor-rich substitute for relish that is rich in probiotics and will aid in the digestion of whatever you are putting it on.

4.13 from 24 votes

Print Pin

Course: Appetizer, Condiment, Side Dish, Snack

Keyword: Cabbage, Fermented, Jalapeno Pepper, Onion, Paleo, Sauerkraut, Sweet Red Pepper, Vegetarian

Prep Time: 30 minutes mins

Servings: 28 – 1 ounce (30 grams)

AUTHOR : Holly Howe

EQUIPMENT

  • Kitchen scale, ideally digital

  • Cutting board and chef’s knife

  • Large mixing bowl

  • 1-quart (L) wide-mouth canning jar or similar sized jar

  • 4-ounce(125 ml) canning jar (jelly jar) (or other "weight")

  • Wide-mouth plastic storage cap. You can also use the lid and rim that comes with the jar.

INGREDIENTS

  • 1 small head fresh green cabbage,, 1-1½ pounds
  • 2 white onions,, baseball sized!
  • 1 sweet red pepper
  • 1 jalapeno pepper
  • 1 tablespoon paprika powder
  • 1/2 teaspoon mustard seeds
  • 1/2 teaspoon celery seeds
  • 1 tablespoon (15 ml) iodine-free salt (fine-grain)

INSTRUCTIONS

  • SET UP. Gather Supplies and Set Up Scale

    In all my recipes, I have you use a kitchen scale to weigh your ingredients. Doing so really does make your life easier and your success almost guaranteed, because you add just the right amount of salt.

    You don’t want to include the weight of your bowl (the tare) in your measurements, so either zero out the scale (usually done with a button on a digital scale or a knob under the tray on a mechanical scale) or write down the tare (bowl) weight.

    Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (15)

  • CHOP. Prep Your Vegetables and Cabbage

    You'll now prepare all your flavoring ingredients and slice your cabbage into thin, ribbon-like strands. In this sauerkraut recipe, I have you dice your flavoring ingredients to try and duplicate the texture of a pickle relish.

    Finely dice your onions and add them to your bowl on the scale.

    With hot peppers, the heat is in the seeds and the inner membrane. Vary the heat by how many seeds you leave in.

    For both the sweet red pepper and jalapeno pepper cut off the stem and scrape out the inner membrane and seeds, but leaving in the seeds of the jalapeno pepper if you like a lot of heat in your ferments.

    Finely dice the peppers and add them to your bowl.

    Measure into your bowl: 1 tablespoon of paprika powder, 1/2 teaspoon of mustard seeds and 1/2 teaspoon of celery seeds.

    Discard the dirty or limp outer leaves of your cabbage, setting aside one of the cleaner leaves for use during the SUBMERGE step.

    Quarter, then slice cabbage crosswise into thin ribbons. I leave the core in, using it as part of my "handle" – but don't actually slice it – because I find it helps to hold the layers of cabbage together making the slicing job easier. See my post on ways to slice cabbage for some more tips.

    Add sliced cabbage to your bowl until the weight of your vegetables and cabbage is 1¾ pounds (28 ounces, 800 grams).

    Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (16)

  • SALT. Create Your Brine

    This is where the magic happens. With the help of some salt, that big bowl of cabbage is condensed down and able to fit into your quart (liter) jar. Really!

    Sprinkle vegetables and cabbage with 1 tablespoon of salt and mix well.

    Then, massage the vegetables with strong hands until moist, creating the brine. If you're worried about getting the hotoils from the jalapeno on your hands,use a spoon to mix and press the mixture to get your brine.

    You should be able to tilt the bowl to the side and see a good-sized puddle of brine, about 2–3 inches in diameter. This process can take anywhere from 2 to 5 minutes. Notice how the mixture shrinks. If you're having trouble getting enough brine, read the tips in my post on dry sauerkraut.

    Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (17)

  • PACK. Pack Mixture into Jar

    Once you notice a small puddle of brine in the bottom of your bowl (you may need to tilt it to one side to see it), it is time to pack the moist mixture into your jar.

    Grab handfuls of the salty, juicy cabbage mixture and pack them into your quart-sized (liter) wide-mouth canning jar, periodically pressing the mixture down tightly with your fist or a large spoon so that the brine rises above the top of the mixture and no air pockets remain.

    To keep the outside of your jar clean, hold the jar over the bowl with a clean hand – usually your left – and then use your other hand for packing the sauerkraut.

    Be sure to leave at least 1 inch of space between the top of the cabbage and the top of the jar. Because we weighed out just the right amount of cabbage to fit in your jar, this should happen automatically.

    Pour any brine left in your mixing bowl into the jar and scrape out any loose bits stuck to the sides of the bowl or to the sides of your jar.

    Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (18)

  • SUBMERGE. Hold Ferment Below Brine

    To make sure your ferment is safe from the "bad guys," you'll use a weight of some sort to hold everything below the brine and a lid to keep out airborne molds and yeasts.

    Take that cabbage leaf you saved during the SETUP step, tear it down to just fit in the jar, and place it on the surface of the packed cabbage. Forgot to save a cabbage leaf? No problem. You can fold a narrow piece of parchment paper to size or even cut an old plastic lid to size.

    Place the 4-ounce jelly jar (or preferred weight) on top of the cabbage leaf, right side up with its lid removed.

    Lightly (to allow for escape of CO2 gases), screw on the white plastic storage lid (or airlock of your choice, following manufacturer's directions).

    I like to label my jars using green or blue painter’s tape and a permanent marker. I note the flavor of sauerkraut I made and the date I started fermenting.

    Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (19)

  • FERMENT. Ferment for 1 to 4 Weeks

    Time now for the friendly bacteria to do their work while you watch and wait. Can you wait 7 days to taste the tangy crunch?

    Place your jar of fermenting sauerkraut in a shallow bowl (to catch the brine that may leak out during the first week of fermentation), out of direct sunlight. Wait for 1 week before opening to sample.

    For what to expect while your batch of sauerkraut is fermentingsee:SALTY Cabbage to SOUR Sauerkraut: Fermentation Signs to Monitor

    You can ferment your sauerkraut for up to 4 weeks. The longer you ferment it, the greater the number and variety of beneficial bacteria that can be produced, though most studies show numbers peaking at 21 days. Many like to check their ferment at the one-week mark and then determine ideal fermentation length for their household. More in the post mentioned above.

    Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (20)

  • STORE. Store in Refrigerator for Up to 1 Year

    After fermenting your sauerkraut, it can be put in your refrigerator and is ready to be eaten.

    Rinse off the outside of the jar. You can take the little jar out. Clean the rim if necessary (sometimes it can get sticky from the brine that overflows), and screw the lid back on tightly. Add to your label how long you fermented the contents.

    Enjoy a forkful or two of your sauerkraut with your meals. It will continue to ferment – aging like a fine wine – but at a much slower rate than before. If the flavors are too intense, leave the jar for a month or two and then eat it. You will be amazed at how the flavors have shifted. See7 Easy Ways to Eat Sauerkraut for more ideas on how to enjoy your homemade jar of powerful probiotics.

    If successfully fermented, your sauerkraut can be kept preserved in your refrigerator for up to a year… at least!

    Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (21)

Notes and Tips

Onions

  1. Yellow onions have a nice balance of astringency and sweet in their flavor and are most often used in cooked dishes.
  2. White onionshave a sharper and more pungent flavor than yellow onions. White onions tend to be more tender than yellow onions.
  3. Red onionsadd a nice color to any dish and are often called for in salads, salsas, and other raw dishes due to their relatively mild flavor.

Jalapeno Peppers

  1. If you don’t like super-hot & spicy foods,cut off the stem and slice lengthwise. You might want to wear a glove for this, or be careful and wash your hands well after. With the tip of a knife or a small spoon, scrape the seeds out. To remove even more heat, also scrape out the inner pithy membrane.
  2. If you like the heat, leave in the seeds and inner membrane.
  3. If your hands are sensitive to the capsicum in the jalapeno pepper, don’t add the jalapeno pepper to your bowl until you have mixed all your cabbage and vegetables together and created your brine. Then, add the diced jalapeno, quickly mix and then pack into your jar. You might also want to consider wearing a pair of thin plastic gloves when making this sauerkraut or use a large spoon when mixing and packing.

Ways to Eat Baseball Sauerkraut

Straight out of the jar, or add to egg or tuna salad sandwich, potato or macaroni salad, deviled eggs, hotdog or hamburger

Did you make this recipe?Tag @MakeSauerkaut on Instagram

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (22)

The Book That Will Transform Your Meals, And… Your Health

Learn to make gut-healing sauerkraut to instantly add delicious flavors to your meals. Step-by-step, easy-to-follow instruction with photos and tips.

YES, PLEASE!

Infographic: 7 Sauerkraut Recipes (In Short Form) to Tantalize Your Tastebuds

Check it out below!

Enter your email address below to be sent a quick guide PDF for seven delicious sauerkraut recipes. It will look similar to the infographic that follows but fit on one page that can be kept on your refrigerator for handy reference.

Sauerkraut Recipe Infographic

Ferment by pictures. Seven recipes to choose from.

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (23)

Last update on 2024-03-09 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT] (2024)

FAQs

Baseball Sauerkraut Recipe [HOME RUN FLAVOR HIT]? ›

It's salty and sour (more so the longer it ferments), but not funky, fishy, spicy, or super sweet. Sure, some recipes call for the addition of spices like juniper berries and caraway seeds, or celery seed and onion powder.

How to add flavor to sauerkraut? ›

Ten Delicious Kraut Additions
  1. Juniper Berries. Small and dark, these little raisin-sized berries pack a flavor punch. ...
  2. Beets. Peeled and grated or thinly sliced, even a tiny bit of beet stains the whole ferment fuchsia. ...
  3. Ginger. ...
  4. Lemon Peel. ...
  5. Dill. ...
  6. Caraway Seed. ...
  7. Fennel. ...
  8. Celery Root (celeriac)

What should homemade sauerkraut taste like? ›

It's salty and sour (more so the longer it ferments), but not funky, fishy, spicy, or super sweet. Sure, some recipes call for the addition of spices like juniper berries and caraway seeds, or celery seed and onion powder.

How does sauerkraut get its flavor? ›

Fermentation: Over time, the naturally occurring lactic acid bacteria on the cabbage begin to ferment the sugars, converting them into lactic acid. This acidification process preserves the cabbage and gives sauerkraut its signature sour taste.

What is the spice in sauerkraut? ›

Making sauerkraut at home

In addition to salt, cabbage can and should be seasoned for more flavor. Caraway seeds and juniper berries are commonly used. Sliced apples are also often added and they add even more flavor. Pick tasty and aromatic apples for that reason.

How to get bitterness out of sauerkraut? ›

Sweeten Canned Sauerkrauts With Apples

Even a tart apple is sweeter than the sharp-tasting sauerkraut, and cooking brings out their sugars. The overall effect of the apple is to sweeten and mellow the sauerkraut in a supporting role without overpowering the sauerkraut's own flavor.

What kind of cabbage makes the best sauerkraut? ›

Round cabbage (also called white cabbage or simply cabbage) is the best cabbage for making sauerkraut. The cabbage is dense with smooth leaves and weighs on average around 2 kg. Light green cabbage will give you the best results!

Should homemade sauerkraut be crunchy? ›

It will soften a bit over time, but it will always be a bit crunchy. If you like to make it less crunchy, use a mandoline style slicer set at 1/8-inch or less. It is nearly impossible to hand-cut such a fine shred. The sauerkraut will soften if you cook, but it will lose the enzymes and beneficial bacteria.

How to make sauerkraut more sour? ›

The more salt, the slower the fermentation and the more acidic your sauerkraut. Use too much salt, though, and you'll inhibit fermentation.

Why does my sauerkraut taste like vinegar? ›

The environment in which your vegetables are immersed has become more acidic and, with that, comes a smell and taste reminiscent of vinegar. Note: lacto-fermentation contains lactic acid, whereas vinegar is made of acetic acid. Vinegar generally smells and tastes spicier.

Why doesn't my sauerkraut taste sour? ›

This won't be bad, as in make you sick, it just won't be probiotic or as tasty. My guess is the lack of pizzazz and sour is likely from the cabbage itself. Depending on the cultivar and time of year cabbages can have very little sugar and starch to break down. It is the sugar that turns into that lovely sour.

What herbs can you add to sauerkraut? ›

Some people like to flavor their sauerkraut with herbs such as dill or caraway seeds. You can also add other veggies such as carrots, garlic, or ginger.

Can you ferment sauerkraut too long? ›

Yes, it is certainly possible to ferment sauerkraut for too long. you'll know this has happened if your sauerkraut is mushy. Ideally, the cabbage should retain a crunch to it. I like to check it every 7 days or so, just to avoid going too long.

Why do you put vinegar in sauerkraut? ›

To Speed Up The Ferment

For example, sauerkraut starts out with a ton of different bacterial cultures, but by day 5, the acid-loving lactic bacteria have taken over. By adding a bit of vinegar to a ferment, it creates an environment that is ideal for acid-loving bacteria, thus speeding up fermentation time.

What are the two types of sauerkraut? ›

The first is the canned shelf-stable kind usually has sugar and is really pickled cabbage. The second is lacto-fermented sauerkraut or cabbage that has been fermented at room temperature with salt until it creates the perfect “sour” flavor.

What is the liquid in sauerkraut called? ›

Kraut juice (called Sauerkrautsaft in German, Zeamă de varză/Moare in Romanian, rasol, rasoj or rasuluk in the Balkans) is a beverage that consists of the liquid in which sauerkraut is cured. It is the juice of the vegetable itself and the pickling brine.

What to add to canned sauerkraut to make it taste better? ›

Optional Flavor Enhancements
  1. Chopped bacon or sausage for added richness and smokiness.
  2. Caraway seeds for a traditional and aromatic touch.
  3. Apple slices or apple cider vinegar for a hint of sweetness.
  4. Juniper berries or mustard seeds for a unique flavor profile.
May 10, 2024

What is the tastiest way to eat sauerkraut? ›

Sauerkraut can be added to soups and stews; cooked with stock, beer or wine; served with sausages or salted meats, and is especially good with smoked fish, like hot-smoked salmon.

Can you add fruit to sauerkraut? ›

Adding an apple to your grated cabbage when making sauerkraut adds an extra benefit. Yes, it provides food for the good bacteria to munch on, but the apple skin also provides food for an exceptional good bacteria known as a super probiotic.

How do you reduce the sour taste in sauerkraut? ›

If your sauerkraut is too sour, there are several things you can do to balance out the flavor. One option is to rinse the sauerkraut under cold water to remove some of the acidity. You can also add a little sugar or honey to the sauerkraut to offset the sourness.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Terence Hammes MD

Last Updated:

Views: 5667

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Terence Hammes MD

Birthday: 1992-04-11

Address: Suite 408 9446 Mercy Mews, West Roxie, CT 04904

Phone: +50312511349175

Job: Product Consulting Liaison

Hobby: Jogging, Motor sports, Nordic skating, Jigsaw puzzles, Bird watching, Nordic skating, Sculpting

Introduction: My name is Terence Hammes MD, I am a inexpensive, energetic, jolly, faithful, cheerful, proud, rich person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.